Mafia Mayhem and Mind-Control Parrots: How Is This TV Show So Dull?

April 21, 2026

https://www.theguardian.com/tv-and-radio/2026/mar/28/portobello-how-can-this-tv-show-about-the-mafia-and-a-mind-controlled-parrot-be-so-wildly-dull

A Personal Bet on HBO Max’s Latest Series

This week, I challenged myself to guess the theme of HBO Max’s latest series. Was it about a vintage market in west London, a peculiar type of mushroom, or perhaps a quaint coastal neighborhood near Edinburgh? Surprisingly, none of my guesses were correct. Instead, the series titled “Portobello” unravels the real-life drama of Enzo Tortora, a renowned Italian TV host wrongly implicated in crimes by the Camorra, an Italian mafia-like criminal organization. Who could have predicted that?

The Peak of Portobello’s Popularity

The variety show “Portobello” once captivated an astonishing 28 million viewers, ranging from nuns to prison inmates, making it a national phenomenon in Italy. Among its diverse audience was Giovanni Pandico, a peculiar-looking Camorrist with paranoid tendencies who obsessively followed Tortora. Pandico believed he had telepathic connections with Tortora, even claiming control over a parrot that appeared on the show. In a strange twist, Pandico sent Tortora 20 lace doilies, requesting they be sold on the show’s “Portobello Market” segment, which added an unexpected layer of complexity to the series.

The Accusation and the Media Circus

The situation escalated when Pandico accused Tortora of not returning the doilies, alleging that Tortora was involved in narcotics trafficking for the Camorra. This baseless claim led to Tortora’s arrest, as authorities eagerly assembled what they hoped would be the trial of the century. The entanglement of fame, politics, and organized crime provides a rich backdrop for the series, hinting at the rise of figures like Berlusconi and Trump, as noted in the show’s promotional materials. The 1980s setting offers a lens through which the series’ creator, Marco Bellocchio, critically examines our current era, seemingly disillusioned with what he finds.

See also  Bring the House Down Review: Revel in the Art of Scathing Critiques!

Public Reaction and Media Exploitation

Following his dismissal from TV, Tortora became the subject of a media frenzy, with his former colleagues gauging public opinion about his guilt or innocence in a superficial manner. Some people suggested he was framed by influential figures, while others insensitively commented on his financial status, overlooking his dire situation. This public spectacle underscores the harsh realities of celebrity and scandal.

Reflections on a Career in Television

Even as Tortora contemplates his career, we see flashbacks of him auditioning acts with genuine earnestness, despite his occasional dismissal of his show as “provincial” and “tear-jerking fluff” or even harsher criticisms. Tortora, who preferred to be called a host rather than a presenter, wrestled with the existential dilemmas of entertaining millions. His charisma and natural aptitude for television did not shield him from personal crises.

The Frustrations of Justice

The series also portrays the justice system harshly, infused with a Kafkaesque sense of absurdity. On the night of his arrest, when Tortora inquires about the charges against him, he’s met with bureaucratic secrecy, as the police refuse to disclose the reasons for his detention. His lawyers resort to collecting newspapers just to piece together evidence for his defense, highlighting the manipulation of public perception through media.

The Long Road of Suffering

If the theme of the series is the feeling of powerlessness, it effectively strips Tortora of his agency, reducing him to a pawn in a drawn-out bureaucratic and media-driven ordeal. Labeling his experience as a “theatre of the absurd,” Tortora endures a repetitive and draining process, which, while realistically bureaucratic, doesn’t necessarily translate to riveting television. A particularly memorable yet subdued scene involves coaxing a parrot from a church rafter, setting a tone far removed from more dynamic crime dramas like “Narcos” or “Ozark.”

See also  From Despair to Acclaimed Author: Autistic Novelist Woody Brown's Inspiring Journey

Struggling with Viewer Engagement

The first episode, lasting 72 minutes with a period-authentic aesthetic and subdued tone, might test the patience of viewers accustomed to more gripping, visually stimulating content. This slow burn approach might not resonate with everyone, leaving some viewers yearning for more action or humor.

Personal Reflections on Viewing

Perhaps my own frustration reflects a modern impatience for fast-paced drama, or maybe I simply expected a different kind of entertainment. As I ponder whether a more straightforward story about organized crime would have been more engaging, I recognize my own potential as one of those public voices quick to criticize without fully grasping the narrative’s intent. “Mi prendo la colpa” – I take the blame.

This article was updated on March 31, 2026. A previous version incorrectly stated that Enzo Tortora had a cocaine addiction and an affair with a production team member. These errors have been corrected in this version.

Similar Posts:

Rate this post

Leave a Comment

Share to...